Cowboys Fans Are Unlikely to Be Excited by Replacing Dak Prescott With Derek Carr.
The Dallas Cowboys face a pivotal decision regarding their quarterback situation heading into the 2025 season, primarily centered around Dak Prescott’s contract negotiations. As Prescott approaches the final year of his current deal, speculation swirls over whether he will sign a lucrative extension with the Cowboys or potentially explore free agency, leaving Dallas without compensation.
In the event Prescott departs, ESPN’s Bill Barnwell has identified Kirk Cousins and Derek Carr as viable veteran replacements. Carr, currently under a hefty contract with the New Orleans Saints, could become available if released due to financial considerations. Despite Carr’s credentials as a four-time Pro Bowler with several seasons surpassing 4,000 passing yards, his recent performances have shown fluctuation, which may not excite all Cowboys fans as a replacement for Prescott.
Prescott’s market value is projected at $212 million over four years, a figure significantly higher than what acquiring Carr would likely cost. If the Saints opt to release Carr, they face a substantial $40 million in dead money, though a post-June 1 designation could mitigate short-term financial impacts.
The Cowboys’ decision hinges not only on financial considerations but also on the team’s long-term quarterback strategy. While Carr offers experience and a solid track record, Prescott’s departure would leave a significant void in leadership and continuity. Dallas could alternatively explore re-signing younger talent like Trey Lance and drafting a quarterback to compete for the starting role, viewing this as a potential avenue to build for the future rather than settling for a stopgap veteran option.
Ultimately, the Cowboys must weigh the immediate impact of retaining Prescott against the cost savings and uncertainties associated with pursuing Carr or other veteran alternatives. The quarterback decision will be critical not only for the team’s performance on the field but also for maintaining fan support and organizational stability moving forward.